News & Articles

Explainer: The Standard of Review in a New Jersey Workers’ Compensation case

Appeals from workers’ compensation courts are directly to  the New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division. R. 2:2-3.  The standard for review of a decision of a Judge of Compensation in most instances is governed by Close v. Kordulak Bros., 44 N.J. 589 (1965). In Kordulak, the Supreme Court held that the standard of review for decision rendered by the Division of Workers’ Compensation is:

whether the findings made could reaosnable have been reached on sufficient credible evidence present int he record, considering the proofs as whole, with due regard to the opportunity of the one who heard the witnesses to judge of their credibility and []with due regard also to the agency’s expertise where such expertise is a pertinent factor.”

Id. at 599.

Judge of Compensation are considered experts on workers’ compensation matters and therefore their findings are entitled to deference. Lewicki v. New Jersey Art Foundry, 88 N.J. 75 (1981). The findings of a Workers’ Compensation judge must be supported by articulated reasons and predicated in evidence. Lewicki, supra. The standard of review assumes that necessary hearings have been held and that the fact findings of the administrative agency are sufficient to afford review. Factual findings are not adequate if they merely summarize the evidence. In re Issuance of Permit by DEP to Ciba-Geigy, 120 N.J. 164, 173 (1990); Lister v. J.B. Eurell Cp., 234 N.J. Super. 64, 74 (App. Div. 1989).

In the case of Manzo v. Local 76B, 241 N.J. Super. 604 (App. Div. 1990), cert. den. 122 N.J. 372 (1990), the Appellate Division explained that the standard set forth in Close v Kordulak, supra, is limited to controversies involving credibility determinations by the trial judge. The Court stated that:

where the focus of the dispute is not on credibility but, rather, alleged error in the trial judge’s evaluation of the underlying facts and the implications to be drawn therefrom, our function broadens somewhat. Where our review of the record ‘leaves us with the definitive conviction that the judge went so wide of the mark that a mistake must have been made,’ we may ‘appraise the record as if we were deciding the matter at inception and make our own findings and conclusions.’

Id. at 609; citing Snyder Realty v. BMW of N. Amer., 233 N.J. Super. 65, 69 (App. Div. 1989).

Download the New Jersey Workers’ Compensation Law Handbook

Download Our New Jersey Workers’ Compensation Law Handbook

This is the 2023 edition of Greg Lois’New Jersey Workers’ Compensation Law Handbook.”

THE MOST PRACTICAL, up-to-date, and easy-to-understand guide to workers' compensation claims in New Jersey. This book is designed for employers, attorneys, claim adjusters, physicians, self-insured employers, and vocational rehabilitation workers. This guide is written in plain English by a New Jersey State attorney and provides a detailed analysis of relevant statutes and regulations; a complete recap of recent court decisions including 2021 & 2022 cases; and a full description of current practice.

Download Now

Learn More About New Jersey Workers’ Compensation Defense at LOIS

For more than 20 years we have represented insurance carriers, self-insured employers, third party claim administrators, and employers before New Jersey’s Division of Workers’ Compensation. Our founding partner, Gregory Lois, is co-author of the LexisNexis “Practice Guide to Workers’ Compensation in New Jersey” (2017, ISBN:9781632838735) and served as Law Clerk to Hon. Joan Mott, Administrative Supervisor of Workers Compensation.

Along with managing partner Greg Lois and a dedicated team of experienced attorneys and paraprofessionals, we handle New Jersey cases from cradle-to-grave. We want to be by your side, moving cases aggressively to closure from the start of litigation all the way through to settlement.

We only assign one attorney and one paralegal to each case. The attorney/paralegal assignments are made based on the court the case will be listed in.

Learn More

Get articles delivered to your inbox, once a month.

Subscribe Today!