201-880-7213

Firm News

When is a treating doctor’s opinion accepted on causation?

Disputes on the causal relationship of an injury are common in the workers’ comepnsation context. Oftern, these disputes arise in the context of an alleged “consequential” injury, where the claimant is alleging that because of “altered gait” or other consequence of a compenaable injury, she developed some other disabling condition. When the

“medical opinion of the clamant’s treating physician [is] neither speculative nor a general expression of possibility and it ‘signifies a probability as to the underlying cause of the claimant’s injury which is supported by a rational basis'” and where there is no conflicting medical evidence, the Board may not reject the treating physician’s uncontroverted medical opinion on causation.

Matter of Maye v. Alton Mfg., Inc., 90 AD3d 1177 (2011), quoting, Matter of Mayette v. Village of Massena Fire Dept., 49 Ad3d 920 (2008).

A recent decision (Matter of New York Presbyterian Hospital and State Insurance Fund, 13 NYWCLR 165 [September 11, 2013]) addressed these questions.

This lays out the following test for when a treating physician’s opinion on causation will be accepted:

  1. Comes from the treating physician;
  2. Is not speculative;
  3. Is not merely expressing a “possible” cause;
  4. states that the condition is at least probably causally related;
  5. is supported by a rational basis; and
  6. there is no conflicting medical evidence.
Download the New York Workers’ Compensation Law Handbook

Download Our New York Workers’ Compensation Law Handbook

The 2023 edition of Gregory Lois’ practical, up-to-date, and easy-to-understand guide to workers’ compensation claims in New York.

This book is designed for employers, attorneys, claim adjusters, physicians, self-insured employers and vocational rehabilitation workers.

Download Now

Learn More About New York Workers’ Compensation Defense at LOIS

We represent insurance carriers, self-insured employers, third party claim administrators, and employers before the New York State Workers' Compensation Board. We handle cases from cradle-to-grave. We want to be by your side, moving cases aggressively to closure from the start of litigation all the way through to settlement.

We only assign one attorney and one paralegal to each case. This means that your team members always have one contact to go to for any questions. We do not have 'hearing attorney' or a 'negotiation attorney' or 'appeal department' or anything else! All of our attorneys handle all of those roles – meaning cases are not 'passed around' as they move through the litigation process. Your risk professional or adjuster always knows who is assigned – because the attorney does not change.

Learn More

Get articles delivered to your inbox, once a month.

Subscribe Today!